How motors work and how to choose the right motor for your project
Tuesday - 25/09/2018 20:35
Choosing the right DC Motor (or DC gear motor) for a specific application can be a daunting task and many manufacturers only provide basic motor specifications.
These basic specifications might not be sufficient for your needs. Listed below are ideal motor specifications and whenever possible, ways to approximate values.
Below is a list of the most common specifications a DC motor manufacturer might list. For most hobbyists the basic information is enough to make an informed decision about which motor to purchase.
The voltage that corresponds to the highest motor efficiency. Try to choose a main battery pack which most closely matches the nominal voltage of your drive motors.
If you operate a motor outside of its nominal voltage, the efficiency of the motor goes down, often requiring additional current, generating more heat and decreasing the lifespan of the motor. Aside from a "nominal voltage" DC motors also have an operating voltage range outside of which the manufacturer does not suggest operating the motor. For example a 6V DC Gear motor may have an operating range of 3-9V; it will not operate as efficiently as compared to 6V, but it will still run well.
No Load RPM:
This is how fast (angular velocity) the final output shaft will rotate assuming nothing is connected to it. If the motor has a gear down and the motor's speed is not indicated separately, the no load rpm value is the shaft speed after the gear down. The motor’s RPM is proportional to the voltage input. “No Load” means the motor encounters no resistance whatsoever (no hub or wheel mounted to the end). Usually the No Load RPM provided is associated with the nominal voltage.
If a motor's power is not listed, it can be approximated. Power is related to current (I)
and voltage (V) by the equation P = I*V. Use the no load current and nominal voltage to approximate the motor's power output. The motor's maximum power (which should only be used for a short time) can be approximated using the stall current and nominal voltage (rather than maximum voltage).
This is the maximum torque* a motor can provide with the shaft no longer rotating. It is important to note that most motors will sustain irreparable damage if subjected to stall conditions for more than a few seconds. When choosing a motor, you should consider subjecting it to no more than ~1/4 to 1/3 the stall torque.
This is the current the motor will draw under maximum torque conditions. This value can be very high and should you not have a motor controller capable of providing this current, there is a good chance your electronics will fry as well. If neither the stall nor the nominal current are provided, try to use the motor's power rating (in Watts) and the nominal voltage to estimate the current: Power [Watts] = Voltage [Volts] x Current [Amps]
A DC motor's general specifications usually include weight, shaft length and shaft diameter as well as motor length and diameter. Other useful dimensions include the location of mounting holes and thread type. If only the length or diameter are provided, refer to an image, photo or scale drawing to get a sense of the other dimensions based on the one known value.
"Torque" is calculated by multiplying a force (acting at a distance away from a pivot) by the distance. A motor rated at a stall torque of 10Nm can hold 10N at the end of 1m. Similarly, it could also hold 20N at the end of 0.5m (20 x 0.50 = 10) and so on. Note: 1 Kg * force of gravity (9.81m/s2) = 9.81N (~10N for quick calculations)
Many motor manufacturers are now listing additional information that can be very useful when selecting the right motor. Below is some additional information you might come across when searching for DC motors:
Voltage vs. RPM:
Ideally, the manufacturer would list the graph of a motor's voltage vs. rpm. For a quick approximate, consider using the no-load rpm and nominal voltage: (nominal voltage, rpm) and the point (0, 0). See “gear down” below for motors with a gear down.
Torque vs. Current:
Current is a value that cannot be easily controlled. DC motors use only as much current as they need. Ideal specifications include this curve, and approximations are not easily reproduced. The stall torque is related to the stall current. A motor that is prevented from turning will consume maximum (“stall”) current and produce the maximum torque possible. The current required to provide a given torque is based on many factors including the thickness, type and configuration of the wires used to make the motor, the magnets and other mechanical factors.
Technical specifications or 3D CAD drawing:
Many robot builders like to draw their robot on the computer before purchasing the necessary parts. Although all motor manufacturers have a CAD drawing with the dimensions, they rarely make it available to the public. Ideal motor dimensions include the basics listed above, as well as mounting hole locations and thread type. Ideally the materials used to make the motor, gears and winding as well as separate dimensions for the motor and the gear down would also be given.
DC motor manufacturers that also produce the corresponding gear down for a motor must list the gear down ratio. The gear down acts to increase torque and reduce rpm. The No Load RPM value given is always that of the last output shaft after the gear down. To find the angular velocity of the motor shaft before the gear down, multiply the value by the gear ratio.
To obtain the motor's stall torque before the gear down, divide the stall torque by the gear down. The material used to make the internal gears is usually plastic or metal and are chosen to be able to withstand the maximum torque rating. Calculate the gear down below given the values before and after gear down.
Accessories: An optical encoder is the most common accessory for a gear motor. Finding the right size of optical encoder for your motor can be very difficult if it is not made from the same company. An optical encoder allows you to track both the direction of rotation and number of revolutions of the motor. With the right code, an optical encoder can also give you the angle of the shaft.
Hubs and Shaft Couplers:
Secondary items such as hubs (used to connect the output shaft to other items) are slowly becoming available for varying sized output shafts. Only a few manufacturers provide generic shaft couplers. If you cannot find the appropriate coupler, consider using spur gears to offset the shaft to that of a different size. The image below shows three different types of couplers. The hole in the hub is for a threaded screw (“set screw”) which presses tightly against the shaft.